Arrivia Survey: 86% of Loyalty Decision-Makers Expect Budgets to Grow, While Only 32% of Consumers Say Their Preferred Brand's Rewards Program Consistently Exceeds Expectations
CX Dive reports on research from travel loyalty provider Arrivia showing consumers' top ask is more valuable everyday rewards (40%), ahead of bigger aspirational rewards (32%). About half of the 250 business leaders surveyed plan to upgrade rewards and redemption in the next 12 months.
Loyalty members want rewards at both ends of the scale, CX Dive reported on November 13, citing research released on November 9 by Arrivia, a travel loyalty platform. In its survey of 2,007 U.S. adults, the top change that would make consumers engage more was more valuable everyday rewards, named by 40%, followed by bigger, more exciting rewards to work toward, at 32%. The most common complaints were rewards that are not valuable enough and rewards that are too hard to earn or redeem.
Arrivia's release sets that against strong stated retention: 90% expect to stay loyal to their preferred brand, but only 32% say its rewards program consistently exceeds expectations. Ashley Wilson, Arrivia's chief client officer, said strong retention "doesn't necessarily mean the program is influencing their behavior."
A separate Arrivia survey of 250 U.S. decision-makers at organizations with at least 250 employees found 86% expect loyalty budgets to grow over the next two years. Rewards and redemption experiences top the list of planned upgrades, ahead of loyalty platform technology and AI tools, with 49% planning to raise AI investment. CX Dive also cited Deloitte Digital's Bobby Stephens, who said the average U.S. consumer belongs to 14 or 15 programs but is active in five or six. Arrivia notes the two samples were not matched, so comparisons are directional.
Why it matters for loyalty teams
Arrivia sells travel and cruise benefits to loyalty programs, and its release leans on findings that favour that product. Discount the travel conclusions accordingly. The budget figure also comes only from organizations with 250 or more employees, so it describes what larger competitors intend to spend, not what a smaller program should.
The finding worth keeping is the order of preference: everyday value ahead of aspirational prizes. The two are not equally expensive. A big reward that few members reach is cheap because most points toward it are never redeemed. Richer everyday rewards are paid out on nearly every visit, so raising them lifts cost in direct proportion to activity. Programs that follow this advice should expect redemption expense to rise before any change in behaviour shows up.
A mid-market operator does not need a platform upgrade to act on this. Check what share of members have ever redeemed anything, then lower the first redemption threshold or add one small reward reachable within two or three purchases. Fund it by trimming the top-tier prize few people reach. If redemption is already high and repeat rates are flat, the problem lies elsewhere and this research does not apply.
Analysis by LoyaltyWire Editorial.